Toxic cadmium found in children’s jewelry

bigstockphoto_Just_Out_Shopping_233(Updated January 13, 2010 – I made a mistake in one of the ppm statement which is now corrected.)

Did you think lead was the only concern in children’s jewelry? Unfortunately, no.

The Associated Press reports that Chinese manufacturers are switching to the toxic metal cadmium in children’s jewelry because they are barred from using lead under the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act (CPSIA). To be honest, I’m not sure that it completely accurate. As stated in the article, jewelry industry veterans say that cadmium has been used in products for Chinese markets for years. I think many of those were imported into the US as well. In my experience testing using my Niton XRF Analyzer, I found cadmium in children’s jewelry before the CPSIA was enacted, although it is probably true that manufacturers looking for a substitute for lead because of the CPSIA may be turning to cadmium, especially since the price of cadmium has plummeted recently, although the more common replacement for lead is zinc.

In any event, the AP articles reports on its investigation involving 103 children’s jewelry items, almost all of which were purchased in November and December of last year. Those 103 items were tested, and 12 of the items contained at least 10% cadmium (or more than 100,000 ppm cadmium). Included in this list are pendants featuring “The Princess and The Frog” characters. The items were purchased at Walmart, Claire’s and a dollar store. In addition, two other items contained lower amounts of cadmium, and 89 of the items were free of cadmium.

According to the AP story, the most contaminated piece was a shocking 91% cadmium by weight, or 910,000 ppm. Other jewelry items tested at 89%, 86% and 84% cadmium by weight.

Cadmium is a known carcinogen. It is also listed on California’s Proposition 65 list of chemicals known to cause cancer or reproductive harm as a reproductive toxicant for males.

Kids don’t have to swallow an item to be exposed. They can get low level doses of cadmium by mouthing, biting or sucking on the jewelry items, as kids tend to do.

The AP investigation also tested the items with high cadmium to see if any exposure would occur if the items were swallowed. This testing involved an acid bath designed to mimic stomach acid. Three flip flop bracelet charms sold at Walmart contained between 84 and 86 percent cadmium. These charms fared the worst in the stormach acid test. One of the charms leached more cadmium in 24 hours than what the World Health Organization would deem a safe exposure over 60 weeks for a 33 pound child.

In several tweets on Sunday, Scott Wolfson. Consumer Product Safety Commission spokesperson, indicated that the CPSC would be investigating the matter and that the CPSC was on its way to China to address the issue. Keep in mind that the CPSIA does not regulate total cadmium content in children’s products. Instead, under the CPSIA, there is a limit for soluble cadmium in paints and coatings used on children’s toys. However, the CPSC can pursue products that the CPSC deems to be a public danger under the Federal Hazardous Substances Act – as it used to do for lead in children’s jewerly before the CPSIA was enacted. And, of course, in California, items that expose a consumer to significant risk level of cadmium must have a Proposition 65 warning.

In addition to jewelry as discussed in the article, I’ve also seen an increase in cadmium turning up in vinyl items. Cadmium compounds can be used to stabilize vinyl just as lead can be used, and with the regulation of lead under the CPSIA, I’ve seen many more vinyl items with cadmium in the last year in my XRF testing.

If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.

Comments

  1. Glad to hear they’re investigating it. This is one reason why I’ve never been a fan of children’s jewelry. Too many recalls because safety isn’t the focus. Cheap is.

  2. I would love to know which items tested free of cadmium.

  3. Janelle Sorensen says:

    Thanks for always staying on top of this, Jennifer! What would we do without you (I shudder to think it). You’re an XRF superhero!

  4. Carolyn – The news article isn’t detailed enough to provide that information, but I’m trying to find out more.

  5. With all the kids China has to provide jewelry for, is it any surprise they have to use any metal they can get their hands on, toxic or not?

  6. Thanks for the information. How many times does China have to poison us before we stop buying from them?

  7. Edith Lucero says:

    What about the plastic jewelry? Do we not have to be careful with them as well? They are all made in China. The rings, necklaces, play dress up shoes and accessories, such as: earrings and clips. Should they be tossed as well?

  8. Plastic jewelry can pose a problem, but the more significant issue right now is inexpensive metal jewelry that can be contaminated with lead and now cadmium. Plastic jewelry may be a problem if it is polyvinyl chloride (PVC), which is usually the soft, flexible plastic, sometimes used as “string.” PVC can be stabilzed with lead or cadmium, and may also contain phthalates.

  9. That is terrific news. It is scary for our children to have jewelries like that. Can I know how to determine if the jewelry has toxic?

  10. Sherrie says:

    Is there a way for us parents to test our children’s jewelery? I purchased a few pieces of children’s jewelry, made in China, at Christmas time (At Wal-Mart) and refuse to let my children wear it until I can be certain it isn’t toxic.

  11. DoctorPsi says:

    This is bad. Why would they use such thing if they know from start that cadmium is toxic.

  12. Anonymous says:

    This is bad.Why would they use such thing if they know from start that cadmium is toxic.I think chinese people need to be put against the wall untill they come to normal once again.

  13. The sad thing is that products (both childrens and adults) will continue to be overlooked and we will probably hear of something else in a couple of months. I guess the best thing (and only) thing to do is continue to look for these problems ourselves.rnrnGreat Post.

Trackbacks

  1. […] toxic cadmium found in children's jewelry | The Smart Mama […]

  2. […] evaluating toxic cadmium in children’s jewelry on Sunday as a substitute for lead, I posted that using cadmium in jewelry pre-dated the lead content limits of the Consumer Product Safety […]

  3. […] – don’t give  children cheap metal jewelry. Just don’t. This warning follows the recently released investigation by the Associated Press that found high levels of cadmium in children’s […]

  4. […] Smart Mama passes along the CPSC warning to take cheap metal jewelry away from kids. It may contain cadmium, a known carcinogen and frequent substitute for lead in […]

Speak Your Mind

*