Why being green is not always being non toxic: hazards of CCA treated and lead painted wood

painted tableGreen is good.  But, sometimes being green isn’t the same as being non toxic.  Fox’s hit television show House hammered that point home last night with its episode Emancipation.  (And I have to say it is sort of fun being able to reference a mainstream hit television show to make a point about toxic chemicals in our homes!) 

So, if you didn’t see last night’s episode, one of the perplexing medical cases involved a young woman.  Of course the team can’t figure out what is wrong with her in the beginning, and investigate her history and her living arrangements.  Turns out, she  had been making furniture out of copper chromated arsenate (CCA) treated wood.  If you aren’t familiar with CCA treated wood, basically, CCA has been used as a preservative for outdoor wood for a number of years.  If you want to know more about it being used in decks and outdoor play structures and how to reduce exposure, read my blog on CCA hazards.  

In any event, as the show’s summary states:

House asks the team what the girl’s homemade furniture looks like. Sawing or burning treated wood releases arsenic into the air and gets absorbed into the internal organs, which is why it did not appear on the blood test. Foreman has the team test her hair for arsenic and then chelate it out of her blood.

Ultimately, it turns out that the arsenic was helping her ’cause she actually had leukemia.  But, for those of us in real life, the arsenic exposure would be of concern. 

And situations like that do happen when re-using or re-purposing materials.  

I came across a similar situation with a couple very into sustainable, green living.  They were expecting their first baby and had me use my Niton XRF analyzer to check items in their home for lead, cadmium, chromium and more.  They had a lot of furniture that they had purchased from thrift stores and antique shops.  It is a very Southern California beachy vibe – older worn wood furniture with peeling paint – very urban shabby chic.  Can you guess the problem?  Almost all of the painted furniture tested high for lead.  The current standard for lead in paints is 600 parts per million (ppm) lead.  Their furniture?  It tested at the lowest at 85,000 ppm, and other pieces much higher.  Not what you want when you are going to have a baby pulling up on the furniture.

So, as much as they were trying to re-used and re-purpose, sometimes it doesn’t make sense.  Painted wood that pre-dates 1978 or CCA treated wood should not be used to make furniture without first confirming the absence of lead and arsenic, respectively.  

If you do have peeling paint furniture, keep in mind that it just isn’t kids eating the paint chips that can elevate their blood lead levels.  No, it can be the lead in dust around the home – kids ingest a lot of dust from their hands, or mouthing objects that get dust collected on them.  If you can’t get rid of a favorite piece, try tucking in a corner where it doesn’t get played with, pulled on, or used.

Video on CCA Treated Wood – What to look for, what to do

A friend forwarded this video on YouTube from two carpenters talking about copper chromated arsenate (CCA) treated wood – how to look for it, what it is and what to do.  As a follow up to my blog on the hazards of CCA treated wood, thought you might like it.  And both of these blogs are a result of the recent reports of arsenic in drinking water being linked to increased risk of diabetes.

Reducing the Kids’ Risk of Arsenic Exposure from Treated Decks and Play Structures

skull and crossbonesReuters UK published an article the other day that a recent study that found a strong link between arsenic and adult-onset diabetes.  The article identifies arsenic in drinking water as the primary source of exposure for adults.  But, it got me thinking about arsenic and the risk of exposure for children, especially as our children go back to school.  So, I thought that re-visiting the topic was a good idea for a blog. 

Arsenic is naturally occurring.  It is probably most infamous because it is an odorless, tasteless, colorless poison that can be readily dissolved in any drink.  It is used in lots of mysteries, although a heavy dose is detectable in a dead body so it isn’t the perfect poison.  A better mystery is the slow poisoning, such as lacing arsenic in powdered sugar doughnuts (anybody flash back to the Flowers in the Attic series?). 

Arsenic is a carcinogen found in groundwater.  We are exposed to arsenic in our drinking water.  The water consumed by 13 million Americans has arsenic present in excess of the drinking water standard, primarily in rural areas. 

But, our kids can also be exposed to arsenic via arsenic treated wood in decks and playgrounds.  Yes, we used arsenic (actually, chromated copper arsenate or CCA) as a preservative for outdoor wood for a number of years.  The EPA banned the manufacture and sale of arsenic-treated wood for most uses in 2004.  But, wood decks and kids’ play sets built before 2004 most often contain arsenic.  70% of the homes in the US are estimated to have arsenic treated structures, and 14% of public children’s playgrounds are estimated to have arsenic-treated wood. 

If you have a wood deck or any outdoor wood structures, or if your school or daycare has any such structure, there is a risk that your kids might be exposed.  Kids can ingest arsenic transferred from when they touch treated wood or nearby soils.  Arsenic exposure is by ingestion – not simply skin exposure.  But kids can certainly become exposed if they place their hands in their mouths after touching arsenic treated wood. 

To understand what to look for, check out this video. If you want to test your wood, or have your school or daycare test its wood, you can order a test kit from the Environmental Working Group.  (Or, you can have me come and do a Healthy Home visit and use my Niton XRF analyzer to test for arsenic, as well as lead, cadmium, chromium, bromine as a measure of flame retardants, etc.  I recently tested the deck and soils of some potted fruits and vegetables on the deck for a client – and we determined that the side walls of the deck were treated and had arsenic, but the soils were clean.) 

If you do have a wood deck from 2004 or before, or an older kids play set, you can take precautions to reduce the potential exposure and protect your kids. 

Smart Mama’s Simple Steps to reduce exposure from arsenic-treated wood: 

  1. Wash hands!  It seems like washing hands is always recommended to reduce chemical exposures, from arsenic to lead.  According to a study published in Environmental Health Perspectives, washing with soap and water removes arsenic from the hands and reduces risk.  The study found that the wash water from children washing their hands after playing on arsenic treated wood had arsenic levels 400% greater than the arsenic levels in wash water from children playing on other structures.  To wash, use a liquid or bar castile soap and wash for 20 seconds.
  2. Seal regularly.  Seal the wood regularly using a non-toxic, water-based paint or sealer.
  3. Replace high traffic areas.  Replacing the entire structure or play yard may be too expensive or impractical, but perhaps you can replace the frequently handled areas, such as handrails.
  4. Skip pressure washing.  As much as your husband may love his pressure washer, don’t use it on arsenic-treated wood as this may result in the release of arsenic from the wood.  If you need to clean, do it gently with liquid castile soap and water, not harsh detergents.  And don’t sand arsenic treated wood – you’ll release arsenic-contaminated dust.
  5. Watch the dirt.  Nearby soils may become contaminated, particularly if they are located where water runoff drains.  Consider making this area inaccessible to children with some bushes, and don’t use for planting edibles.